which protects better in the cold?

[Kaela]

This probably seems like a really stupid question, but for nasty cold temperatures, I was wondering which base works better....petroleum/mineral oil based products or natural products?

Personally, I'm a natural ingredient fan, but I do know that in the winter time, nothing seals out dryness from the cold better than thick lotion...if not vaseline itself for my skin.
This wouldn't apply to hair too would it?

 

[Nacai23]

For me shea butter worked the best during the winter. My fav is kemi oyl shea butter pomade. Very thick and moisturizing.

 

[TsAngel]

I like Shea and EVOO mixed.